On Emotions and Needs

Emotions are subconscious, instantaneous appraisals of a given situation or its elements. But it is not just the objective characteristics of a situation that get appraised, because otherwise most people would feel the same way about the same situations. In fact, our emotional response is determined by our mind’s judgment on whether the situation in question comports with our needs, goes against them, or doesn’t have much impact on their fulfillment.

Let’s consider an example of somebody having strong emotions upon finding himself at a party. If his mind subconsciously assesses the situation as not conducive to his goals, the person will feel unease. For instance, if he was looking forward to a lowkey night of board games but instead finds himself surrounded by loud music and dancing people, he is likely to experience negative emotions: irritation, apprehension, disappointment, anger, etc. The specific emotional response would depend on the person’s temperament and overall disposition, but it is sure to be negative, at least at first.

Note that in the above example, there is nothing wrong with the party per se. Many people seem to enjoy it and experience a slew of positive emotions: joy, surprise, anticipation, etc. More than that, even the person in our example thoroughly enjoyed a similar party a mere week before. So, his current negative emotions cannot be explained by the objective properties of the party itself. Instead, his negative emotions are caused by the fact that he is not getting the kind of lowkey pastime he wanted, not by the loud music or strangers dancing around him.

With a little introspection, the person in question should be able to understand that there is nothing wrong with the party itself. Upon changing his expectations for the night, he may even come to enjoy it. The problem begins when people are unaware of the relationship between their needs and the subconsciously assessed situation that seems to threaten them.

Let’s look at another example. A couple is on their first date. The woman hints that she wouldn’t mind continuing at the man’s place. The man apparently wants the same. So, it stands to reason that he should be pleased with the situation and experience positive emotions. Yet he does not. In fact, he feels wary about the direction of the date or even the entire relationship with the woman. Why so?

There can be many reasons. One, the man may consider such behavior promiscuous. Two, he may be worried that after having one too many drinks, he will not perform. Three, he may become concerned that the next day the woman will claim that he has taken advantage of her inebriated state. Four, he may think that his place looks squalid and could ruin the woman’s impression of him. Five, he may have just been through a painful breakup and feels psychologically vulnerable. There are many more potential explanations for why the man may be experiencing negative emotions when the situation seems to be calling for positive ones.

What all those explanations have in common is that the man himself may not see them as reasons for his negative emotions. Worse than that, he may even confuse himself and decide that he is turned off by the woman’s perceived promiscuity when, in reality, the actual cause of his apprehension is the sorry state of his apartment. Thus, the man’s mind may have subconsciously assessed the woman’s forward suggestion as a threat to his need for a certain image but provided a very different conscious explanation for the emotion of apprehension—namely, the woman’s undignified behavior. Or it can be the other way around. The man may be subconsciously repulsed by his date’s accessibility but, knowing that such views are considered passé, he persuades himself that he has reacted out of concern about the legal risks of a drunken one-night stand.

This brings us to an important realization: emotions are the keys to understanding our needs. Because of their instantaneous and subconscious nature, they can often be misleading, illogical, unfair, and flat-out maladaptive. But behind every emotion, there is always a subconscious assessment of the state of our needs. If, upon experiencing a negative emotion, you discover which exact need your mind has assessed as threatened by the situation, it is the first and most important step in dealing with it in a constructive manner.

Emotions · Needs · Action

What Emotions Tell Us

Emotions are rapid appraisals of how a situation relates to our needs.

Situation What is happening?
Subconscious appraisal How does this situation relate to my needs? The event itself does not determine the emotion.
Example

You wanted a quiet evening. The loud party frustrates that need, producing irritation or apprehension.

Example

You wanted stimulation or social contact. The party supports that need, producing joy or anticipation.

Example

The party neither supports nor threatens anything important to you, so it produces little emotional response.

Use the emotion as a clue, not a command

An emotion can reveal the state of a need without accurately judging the situation itself.

Let’s consider the first-date example again. Imagine that the man is turned off by the woman’s accessibility but persuades himself that his apprehension is due to the state of his apartment. He may improve his living space all he wants. He may move to a five-bedroom penthouse downtown. And yet, that will not help his romantic life unless he honestly admits to himself that what he needs is not a better condo but a more puritan partner.

Just like will, emotions are a tool for behavioral regulation. They direct us towards what our minds consider the fulfillment of our needs and away from what our minds consider a threat to our needs. However, emotions are a relatively primitive form of behavioral regulation that we share with many higher-order animals. By exercising willpower, we can make our needs more sophisticated and better aligned with our long-term wellbeing. But to do so, we must first understand what needs currently drive our emotional reactions. And for that, we must learn to pay close attention to our emotions without becoming their slaves.

Next
Next

On Will, Freedom of Will, and Willpower